This SEO action plan has been generated by Waikay for demonstration purpose
👉 Get a free SEO action plan for your website

Executive Summary

This action plan analyses how Maybelline UK covers the topic of mascara across its public website content. Mascara is a high-intent cosmetics category where search visibility and conversion depend not only on product pages, but on how well educational content, benefit-driven segmentation, and internal linking support product discovery.

Key findings

Strong foundations
Maybelline benefits from strong brand authority and a broad mascara product range. Existing product and category pages provide a solid base for topical coverage and commercial intent.

Clear content gaps
Mascara-related content is fragmented across product listings, with limited educational guidance to help users compare options or choose the right product. Benefit-led themes such as waterproof wear, lengthening vs. volumising effects, and use-case-driven selection are under-represented or not clearly structured.

Primary opportunity
The main opportunity lies in consolidating mascara content into a clear, structured topic hub supported by buying guides, FAQs, and attribute-based segmentation. This would improve both user experience and topical authority for competitive mascara-related queries.

Priority actions

Create a central “Mascara” content hub
Bring together products, guides, comparisons, and FAQs under a single, clearly signposted entry point.

Expand benefit- and use-case-driven content
Develop supporting content around key selection criteria such as waterproof formulas, volume vs. length, wear time, and application needs.

Strengthen internal linking between guides and products
Ensure educational content consistently routes users to relevant product pages and vice versa.

Generate an Action Plan with Waikay >

Audit content

Strengths

Audited website

maybelline.co.uk

  • Extensive mascara product portfolio with multiple product lines (Colossal, Lash Sensational, Sky High, etc.)
  • Dedicated mascara category pages with clear navigation paths
  • Product-specific pages with detailed information for each mascara variant
  • Educational content on mascara application and selection (e.g., mascara for eye colors)
  • Multiple tutorial pages for mascara application techniques

Competitors

elfcosmetics.co.uk

  • Dedicated ‘Mascara Guide’ page providing educational content
  • Clear branding of mascara benefits in product names (e.g., ‘Lash n Roll’, ‘Lash Xtndr’)
  • Travel size mascara options prominently featured
  • Vegan and cruelty-free messaging integrated into product pages
  • Value proposition clearly communicated through product descriptions

nyxcosmetics.co.uk

  • Specialized mascara formulations (e.g., Cannabis Sativa Seed Oil Mascara)
  • Clear waterproof mascara category and labeling
  • Benefit-focused product naming (‘Worth the Hype’, ‘On the Rise’)
  • Dual-purpose products (e.g., brow and lash mascaras)
  • Value messaging incorporated into product titles

Content Gaps

Structural Gaps

Dedicated mascara guide/education pageSignificant
Unlike e.l.f.’s comprehensive mascara guide, Maybelline lacks a centralized educational resource specifically for mascara selection and application
Waterproof mascara category organizationSignificant
No dedicated section or filter for waterproof mascaras, unlike NYX which clearly segments waterproof options

Thematic Gaps

Vegan/cruelty-free messagingCritical
Limited emphasis on vegan or cruelty-free formulations compared to competitors who highlight these qualities prominently
Value proposition communicationSignificant
Competitors more effectively communicate value and worth in product naming and descriptions

Critical Topic Gaps

Vegan MascaraCritical
Limited or no content highlighting vegan formulations, which is increasingly important to consumers
Both e.l.f. and NYX prominently feature vegan messaging in their mascara product pages
Value PropositionCritical
Insufficient content explaining why Maybelline mascaras are worth their price point
NYX has ‘Worth the Hype’ product line and e.l.f. emphasizes affordability and quality throughout their content

Significant Topic Gaps

Waterproof MascaraSignificant
Underdeveloped content about waterproof mascara options and benefits
NYX features a dedicated ‘Worth the Hype Waterproof Mascara’ product page and highlights water-resistance
Professional Mascara TipsSignificant
Limited professional makeup artist recommendations and techniques
Competitors offer more professional application tips and techniques from makeup artists

Undermentioned Topics

Mascara PrimerModerate
Despite having primer products, there’s minimal educational content about the benefits and usage of mascara primers
Competitors more thoroughly explain the role of primers in mascara application
Product Advertising ClaimsModerate
Insufficient content backing up advertised benefits with explanations or evidence
Competitors provide more detailed explanations of how their products deliver on advertised claims

Recommendations

Content Creation

Comprehensive Mascara GuideHigh Priority
Content Type: Educational resource page
Create a dedicated ‘Ultimate Mascara Guide’ page that helps users select the right mascara based on their needs (volume, length, curl), explains different wand types, application techniques, and includes comparison charts
Vegan and Cruelty-Free MascaraHigh Priority
Content Type: Product category page
Develop a dedicated section highlighting vegan-friendly and cruelty-free mascara options, explaining ingredients and ethical commitments

Content Enhancements

Waterproof MascaraMedium Priority
Existing Content: Various product pages with waterproof options
Create a ‘Waterproof Mascara’ filter and category on the main mascara page, and enhance product descriptions with specific waterproof benefit information
Mascara PrimerMedium Priority
Existing Content: https://www.maybelline.co.uk/all-products/eye-makeup/mascara/lash-sensational-sky-high-primer-mascara-makeup
Expand content about the benefits and application techniques for mascara primers, with before/after visuals and step-by-step instructions

Structural Improvements

Mascara Benefits NavigationHigh Priority
Implement a benefit-based navigation system that allows users to filter mascaras by desired outcome (volumizing, lengthening, curling, etc.)
Value Proposition MessagingMedium Priority
Revise product descriptions to better communicate value proposition and worth, highlighting unique selling points compared to competitors

Implementation Timeline

30 Days

  • Create a ‘Comprehensive Mascara Guide’ educational page with selection advice, application techniques, and comparisons
  • Develop content highlighting vegan and cruelty-free mascara options

60 Days

  • Implement benefit-based navigation filters on mascara category pages
  • Create a ‘Waterproof Mascara’ category and enhance product descriptions with waterproof benefits

90 Days

  • Expand content about mascara primers with tutorials and visuals
  • Revise product descriptions to better communicate value propositions and worth

Additional Observations

Competitive Differentiation

Maybelline has strengths in product variety and specific mascara lines that are well-known (Sky High, Lash Sensational), but lacks clear organization and educational content compared to competitors. The brand could better leverage its extensive product range by improving navigational structure and highlighting unique benefits more clearly.

Content Strategy Recommendations

Develop a mascara-specific content pillar with interconnected educational resources, product pages, and application tutorials

Incorporate more user-generated content showing before/after results with different mascaras to build credibility and demonstrate value

Create an Action Plan with Waikay >

Disclaimer
This action plan is an automated analysis of publicly available website content, generated by Waikay for illustrative and strategic purposes. It does not assess internal processes, legal compliance, or organisational performance. All brand and organisation names are used for descriptive purposes only.